Music, what is appropriate in an Adventist church? This is a topic of great dispute today. It's also one that I find myself compelled to share my thoughts about. You can choose to agree or disagree. If you are one that thinks electric guitar and drums belong in the Sanctuary, I pray you will consider my thoughts and ask God to guide your thoughts.
First, just a reminder that I write that from the perspective of a life-long Adventist, not someone new to our denomination.
Last summer, I visited the small church I grew up in. I was more than disappointed when the church service began with a 40+ minute "worship praise" segment. There were a few things that didn't sit well in my gut. First, I don't sing. I long for the day I am in heaven and can carry a tune. So to be expected to not only sit and listen to music that I was uncomfortable with in God's house, but to be expected to stand up the whole time, was a bit much for me. Now I will say that the music they played wasn't what I would automatically put into the Christian rock category and there weren't any drums banging away. The music was far too loud for sure and definitely had more of a beat than I was comfortable with for worship in God's house.
Last week, I again went to visit my hometown. I took a walk with my friend who was on the trip with me who is someone that has been a Christian for a long time but has only been studying the SDA message for about 6 months. While this person has come to accept the Sabbath truth, there is still a period of growth to learn just what the Adventist lifestyle is all about. We went for a walk so I could show him my home church. It was a Wednesday evening and the front door of the church was open with a couple of cars out front. So we stuck our heads in to see if it would be an appropriate time to see the inside. There were two men there, one I know who leads the worship praise team. I saw a set of drums on the platform in the sanctuary...my heart was sad. The praise team leader very nicely asked if we would like to stay and listen to them practice. I replied that I didn't think drums were appropriate in God's house. We had a small discussion that each of us have done our own study on the subject, we have different conclusions. I thanked him, after showing my friend around and we left, not staying to listen.
On the walk home, I was asked "couldn't you keep your mouth shut?" Well, I explained my point of view to my friend who is learning about Adventism. Over the past few days, I've thought more about this matter and find myself sitting down to write about it on my blog.
The thing I ponder is not whether I
could keep my mouth shut because I could certainly have chosen to do that. Rather,
should I have kept my mouth shut? Obviously, my writing here is proof that I am not convicted after much prayer, that I should have. I never meant to judge those at the church and truly believe their hearts are in the right place, I just disagree. I was careful not to tell them they shouldn't have the drums, instead I told them
I wasn't comfortable with the drums and I made the choice to leave.
So I ask myself, why is it that this topic bothers me so much and why am I so convicted that this is a serious problem growing in our churches. Before going further, I want to recap my own background to give you some insight. If you have read the "How This Started" section of this blog, you know about my background. I never went off the wild path of rebellion so many SDA youth do but I wasn't perfect either. One of the distractions I found myself enjoying was rock music. I went to academy and college in the 80's which meant Def Leppard, Van Halen and so forth and I had lots of their albums and went to a few concerts. However, in those years when I was listening to lots of rock in my car and home, I never felt it was appropriate in God's house. God's house is special and is to be treated holy.
My first encounter with the drums and guitars in an SDA church was about 10 years ago when I visited the La Sierra campus and went to their young adult Sabbath School. When the music started up, I couldn't tell the difference between that "worship" music and when I had gone to rock concerts. I got up and left and went searching for another SS group to join which luckily at that large campus I was able to do.
I've since seen the developing trend in our churches. It's not just the music either, it's the coffee and donuts on Sabbath. I visited another church in the Phoenix area last summer because Pastor Doug was speaking in their youth Sabbath School and I thought it would be a great opportunity to hear him in a small group setting. I got there early and was warmly greeted which was wonderful. I was then offered fresh coffee and told the donuts were on the way. When the donuts arrived, it was obvious they had been purchased that morning...on the Sabbath. I was appalled to think that this was occurring when someone like Pastor Doug was on his way to talk to the group, not to mention this church was conducting a huge evangelistic series and including some wonderful health nuggets at the beginning of each meeting. I knew that the series was close to the segments when the Sabbath truth would be taught. I told the person who offered me the coffee thank you but that I didn't believe it was appropriate to serve during SS. I sat there in silence trying to figure out how they could reconcile preaching the health message and the Sabbath while blatantly contradicting it. Again, should I have kept my mouth shut?
What is it that bothers me so bad? Here it is. Every time I've asked someone who is serving the coffee and donuts, or leading the loud music why, the answer I get is that we need to be more like other churches to bring more people into our denomination. WOW, that right there should alarm us. It's WHY this bothers me so much.
Would any faithful Adventist think that starting Sunday services is the right way to draw others to Christ through truth? Would any honorable Adventist school start teaching evolution as fact rather than creation in order to increase attendance? If not, then why should any faithful Adventist church whose desire it is to bring others to Christ through the love of the truth start acting like other churches to accomplish it?
There are many examples in the Bible of what happens when the Godly start acting like their neighbors. Let's look at Seth, from Patriarchs & Prophets p.81 we see that the two classes of Seth's and Cain's offspring remained separate. "So long as this separation continued, they (Seth's group) maintained the worship of God in its purity. But in the lapse of time they ventured, little by little, to mingle with the inhabitants of the valleys. This association was productive of the worst results."
You see, satan is a master of deceit and his main tool in Christianity throughout the centuries has been to deceive through compromise. He twists the truth just enough that it's close enough to the truth for Christians to easily justify it as acceptable. The obvious compromises to Adventists are the Sabbath vs. Sunday, creation vs. evolution, the state of the dead, and the secret rapture. Why is it that so many Adventists are willing to lower their guard when it comes to music and how we treat God's house? To willfully break not just the heath message when bringing donuts to church, but breaking the very Sabbath they claim to be keeping by buying the donuts on their way to church?
I have a friend who has pointed out that the Bible has examples of loud music being acceptable such as Mariam playing her tambourine. I would point out that Mariam did not play her tambourine in the most holy place of the tabernacle and our sanctuaries are our times "most holy place" where God dwells with us and we come to worship Him who created us.
If the wonderful simplicity of the truth in the Scriptures, presented in love and reverence of God isn't enough to sway a heart to accept salvation, then perhaps it's the love or the truth that's really missing from the message and not the music that is the problem.
Here is a link to an reference on a research project regarding Christian rock (let's face it though, the term Christian rock is an oxy moron).
http://www.av1611.org/crock/crock1.html